2012 Miss New York Contestants in alphabetical order by title
Contestant Order & Preliminary Groupings
| Nu | Psi |
| Interview: Thursday AM Swimsuit + Gown: Thursday Talent + On Stage Question: Friday |
Interview: Thursday PM Talent + On Stage Question:Thursday Swimsuit + Gown: Friday |
| 1. Metropolitan - Shannon Oliver | 14. Bronx - Nardeen Billan |
| 2. Empire State - Danielle Trumbull | 15. LI-Metropolis - Daphaney Jacquitte |
| 3. Thousand Islands - Allison Carlos | 16. New York City- Mallory Hagan |
| 4. Empire Rose - Katelynn Smith | 17. Manhattan - Katie Berry |
| 5. Finger Lakes - Caitlin Nolan | 18. Brooklyn - Maria DeSantis |
| 6. Liberty City - Jessica Johnson | 19. Verrazano - Christina Moore |
| 7. Niagara - Desiree Wiley | 20. Upstate NY - Rayna Reid |
| 8. Southern NY - Mikhaila Leinbach | 21. Fonda Fair - Misti-Lynn Hilts |
| 9. Buffalo - Lonna McCary | 22. Staten Island - Jamie Lynn Macchia |
| 10. Gotham City - Acacia Courtney | 23. Fulton County - Colleen Gagne |
| 11. Westchester - Katie Guevarra | 24. Mohawk Valley = Courtney Sheridan |
| 12. Western NY - Jesse Ladoue | 25. Kings County - Jaleesa Peterkin |
| 13. Richmond County - Stephanie Accardo | 26. Greater Rochester - Nina Davuluri |
STAY IN TOUCH ...